Burning through munitions to support wars in Ukraine and Iran, Pentagon officials have made deals with foreign partners and adapted to emerging threats in an effort to ramp up U.S.munitions production and build up stockpiles.
Yet an “overarching” plan tying together goals, strategy, metrics, and oversight is still needed to ensure the military services have the weapons they need to protect national interests, the Government Accountability Office writes in a new, unclassified report released Nov. 19. The report follows by two months a classified version that GAO said exposed “trends in DOD munitions inventories, persistent shortfalls, and how these shortfalls have affected DOD’s support to war plans.”
GAO’s unclassified report cites two unfilled needs affecting the sprawling munitions enterprise:
- A high-level office empowered with the authority and respoinsibility to develop, manage, and execute a comprehensive, department-wide munitions program
- Centralized, consistent, top-level oversight of munitions data
U.S. military leaders have formeda number of new munitions plans in recent years. GAO cited the Air Force’s 2023 munitions “roadmap” charting its five-year outlook; the Pentagon’s National Defense Industrial Strategy from early 2024, which highlighted the need to bolster the munitions industrial base; and the Army’s Ammunition Plant Modernization Plan of 2025. It also cited working groups created to focus on munitions, such as the Munitions Acceleration Council and the Joint Industrial Base Working Group.
But GAO concluded the Department of Defense needs a centralized plan for embracing common goals, metrics, and best practices to better manage the munitions enterprise.
“Without developing an overarching munitions plan that links munitions production and funding to munitions total requirements and identifies long-term goals, strategies for achieving such goals, and metrics to gauge progress, DOD and the services are not well-positioned to effectively address persistently low munitions inventories,” the report states.
Failure could mean “investing in munitions that are projected to exceed the total munition requirement,” the authors wrote.
A cetral authority with the resources to manage the challenge is also needed, the report says. It noted that the offices that oversee industrial base and munitions policy lack the budget authorities to solve problems, and working groups like the Munitions Acquisition Council lack decision-making authority.
“Successful management requires committed leadership that empowers managers to make decisions, and holds them accountable for the outcomes achieved at all levels of an organization,” the GAO authors wrote. Indeed, the military services want that kind of centralized oversight, GAO said.
“Service officials stated that without an office with dedicated leadership to address munitions challenges, it may be difficult to realize progress in addressing munitions shortages at any level,” GAO officials said.
The Pentagon, in a formal response to the report, agreed it needs an overarching plan and should create an office to oversee it, indicating that the Office of the Undersecretary of Defense for Acquisition and Sustainment will take the lead.
That office already leads the Munitions Acquisition Council and “provides a means to coordinate actions addressing priority munitions production, acquisition, defense industrial base, and supply chain challenges,” wrote Acting Principal Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for Acquisition David S. Cadman in the response.
Building Better Data
Each of the military services is responsible for collecting and maintaining munitions inventories, and the data they collect is pulled into the centralized Munitions Readiness Initiative database, theoretically providing a “near real time” picture of total stockpiles, GAO reported. But its auditors found that Pentagon officials have “limited oversight over this tool” and confidence in the data’s accuracy is lacking.
Information is not regularly crosschecked or reconciled with each of the services’ individual databases, GAO said, meaning Washington leaders can be reliant on outdated or incorrect data.
“Officials from all four services said more regular reconciliations related to munition inventory changes would help ensure the accuracy of their information being displayed by MRI,” the GAO report states.
A related problem is that each of the services collects unique data on their munitions, and the Pentagon lacks a system to describe and standardize the data when it is consolidated. Instead, experts make judgement calls for cross-service comparisons, GAO said, sometimes based on “ad-hoc … discussions.”
“DOD is limited in its ability to monitor how data is aggregated or whether certain data quality standards are met, potentially affecting the accuracy of information in MRI,” auditors concluded.
GAO recommended Pentagon leaders establish regular reconciliation to ensure data accuracy and that the Penagon should set comprehensive standards and practices to standardize munitions tracking.